نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Introduction and Purpose: Today, marketing is recognized as one of the most fundamental pillars of organizational success in the competitive business environment. With the expansion of commercial enterprises and the increasing diversity of services and products, marketing has evolved from a merely operational function into a high-level strategic concern. Rapid advances in digital technologies, big data, artificial intelligence, and machine learning have extended the boundaries of traditional marketing and given rise to the emerging concept of "smart marketing." This dynamic, data-driven approach leverages advanced analytical tools to identify hidden patterns in customer behavior, forecast market changes, personalize communications, and optimize resource allocation. In such a complex and high-risk environment, managers are compelled to systematically assess potential risks associated with marketing decisions and adopt a calculated and intelligent approach based on reliable data and scientific analysis. Despite the growing importance of this concept, a significant knowledge gap remains regarding the dimensions, components, prerequisites, and consequences of implementing smart marketing in manufacturing companies. Therefore, the present study was designed with three interrelated objectives: first, to gain an in-depth understanding of smart marketing and provide a comprehensive conceptualization of the concept; second, to systematically analyze and identify the factors influencing its successful establishment and implementation; and third, to identify and explain the various outcomes of adopting this approach in manufacturing firms. This research aims to develop a comprehensive and context-specific model that not only enriches the theoretical literature in this field but also provides practical and effective guidance for senior marketing managers seeking to adopt smarter marketing practices.
Method: In terms of research paradigm, the present study adopts a mixed-methods approach with an inductive orientation, using qualitative data to explore the dimensions of the phenomenon and quantitative methods to prioritize its components. In terms of purpose, the study is applied, while in terms of research design and data collection, it follows an exploratory sequential approach, with the qualitative phase preceding the quantitative phase. The statistical population consisted of senior marketing managers of manufacturing companies in Lorestan Province. Using purposive sampling, 20 managers with at least 10 years of managerial experience and familiarity with information systems and data mining were selected. Data collection continued until theoretical saturation was achieved. Specifically, following the identification of the last new code, two additional interviews were conducted; as no further codes emerged, theoretical saturation was confirmed. The data collection instrument in the qualitative phase consisted of in-depth, semi-structured interviews. Its validity was established through content and theoretical validity, while its reliability was confirmed using intra-coder and inter-coder reliability assessments, with coefficients exceeding 80%. Qualitative data were analyzed using MAXQDA software through directed content analysis and open, axial, and selective coding. In the quantitative phase, a pairwise comparison questionnaire was administered to the same 20 experts using the Fuzzy Cognitive Mapping (FCM) method. The questionnaire's validity was established through content validity, and its reliability was confirmed using the test-retest method, yielding a correlation coefficient of 0.87. Quantitative data were analyzed through the following stages: constructing the cognitive map, calculating the relationship matrix, determining edge weights, and simulating scenarios using specialized software.
Findings: In the qualitative phase, 10 factors influencing smart marketing were identified, including digital technology and infrastructure, data quality and accuracy, customer behavior analysis, competitor and market analysis, information systems integration, specialized human resource capabilities, a data-driven organizational culture, organizational agility and flexibility, senior management support, and digital maturity and technological readiness. In addition, 10 key outcomes were identified: improved strategic decision-making, reduced environmental costs, enhanced customer experience, strengthened brand positioning, increased customer loyalty, acquisition of new customers, identification of opportunities and threats, integration of organizational data and knowledge, reduced time-to-market, and the creation of a sustainable competitive advantage. In the quantitative phase, the prioritization of the influencing factors revealed that data quality and accuracy, organizational agility and flexibility, and a data-driven organizational culture exerted the greatest influence. Meanwhile, enhanced customer experience, improved strategic decision-making, and the integration of organizational data and knowledge were identified as the most important outcomes.
Conclusion: The overall findings indicate that smart marketing is a multidimensional and systematic construct whose successful implementation depends significantly on the quality of input data, organizational structural flexibility, and the institutionalization of an evidence-based culture. In other words, investing in advanced technologies alone, without taking into account an organization's technological infrastructure and human capabilities, cannot produce desirable results. Furthermore, outcomes such as enhanced customer experience and improved strategic decision-making demonstrate that smart marketing not only generates operational and financial benefits for companies but also has the potential to serve as a sustainable source of competitive advantage, thereby strengthening an organization's market position. Based on these findings, it is recommended that managers of manufacturing companies, before implementing any smart marketing system, prioritize the improvement of data collection and processing procedures, the training and empowerment of human resources, and the establishment of agile organizational structures. It is also suggested that future research investigate the moderating roles of variables such as organizational size, industry type, and level of digital maturity in the relationship between the influencing factors and outcomes of smart marketing. Furthermore, comparative studies of manufacturing and service companies are recommended to develop more precise and generalizable models.
کلیدواژهها English